Menus

Smoked Fish Spread

Smoked whitefish and pickled vegetables, served with club crackers and lemon wedges

Peel and Eat Shrimp

Cocktail sauce, lemon, choose hot or cold

gluten free

Crab Cake

Traditional style blue crab cake, lightly breaded and seared, topped with pineapple and jalapeño salsa, key lime aioli

Grouper Nuggets (when available)

Black grouper bites breaded and fried, served with Critter tartar sauce

Crunchy Fried Shrimp

Sea Critter’s signature almond-crusted shrimp, with house-made cocktail sauce

Fried Calamari

Tender calamari breaded and fried in our own seasoned flour, served with Sweet Thai Chili Sauce

Hush Puppies

Lightly fried cornbread fritters served with a house-made remoulade for dipping

Tomato Crab Bisque

Our signature tomato basil bisque topped with a mound of chilled Blue Crab just before serving

gluten free

Critter House

Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, feta crumbles, sunflower seeds, sun-dried tomato vinaigrette

gluten free

Caesar

Crunchy romaine hearts, garlic herb croutons, shredded parmesan cheese, lemon caesar dressing

Greek

Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, pepperoncini, cucumbers, olives, red onions, peppers, feta crumbles, oregano vinaigrette

gluten free

Add-Ons

Shrimp, Chicken, or Fresh Fish (Choose either Grilled or Blackened)

gluten free

BBQ Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breasts brushed with a tangy BBQ sauce, with lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun

The Critter Burger

8 oz Angus beef patty, grilled with lettuce and tomato and special sauce on a brioche bun

Maine Lobster Roll

Slow poached lobster meat, celery, tossed with an herbed buttermilk dressing, served on a New England style bun

Fresh Catch Sandwich

Choose from today’s choice of market-fresh fish prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried or crunchy almond-crusted

Cuban

House-smoked mojo pork, ham, salami, swiss cheese, yellow mustard sauce and pickles served on pressed Ybor Cuban bread

Today’s Fresh Catch

Choose from today’s choice of market-fresh fish prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried, or crunchy almond-crusted and choice of two sides

gluten free

BBQ Chicken Plate

Grilled chicken breasts brushed with a tangy BBQ sauce, served with choice of two sides

gluten free

Dos Fish Tacos

Flour tortilla, pineapple pico, chipotle crema, pickled red onion, and cilantro. Choose from today’s choice of market-fresh fish prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried, or crunchy almond-crusted, served with creamy coleslaw and thick-cut fries

Fish And Chips

Beer battered haddock, Critter tartar sauce, served with creamy coleslaw and thick-cut steak fries

Sirloin Steak

Grilled grass-fed beef, served with choice of two sides

gluten free

Crab Cakes

Traditional style blue crab cakes, lightly breaded and seared, topped with pineapple and jalapeño salsa, key lime aioli, served with choice of two sides

Lobster Pasta

Maine Lobster medallions, spinach, basil, vine-ripened tomatoes, sautéed in a lobster white wine butter sauce, parmesan cheese with angel hair pasta

Sea Scallops

Jumbo sea scallops, with tartar sauce, prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried, or crunchy almond-crusted, served with creamy coleslaw and thick-cut steak fries.

gluten free

Jambalaya

House-made jambalaya with andouille sausage, shrimp and chicken, served over rice

gluten free

Shrimp & Grits

Shrimp and andouille sausage sauteed with red bell pepper and onions in a cajun cream sauce, served on top of creamy smoked gouda grits

Caribbean Rice

gluten free

Creamy Coleslaw

gluten free

Black Beans

gluten free

Thick Cut Steak Fries

Sautéed Vegetables

gluten free

Sweet Potato Fries

Grilled Cheese "Better than Mom's"

Served with french fries, rice or vegetables

"Old Salty's" Fried Shrimp (4)

Served with french fries, rice or vegetables

Kid's Burger

Served with french fries, rice or vegetables

"Go Fish" Fried Grouper Nuggets

No "square fish" served here! Served with french fries, rice or vegetables

Chicken Tenders

Served with french fries, rice or vegetables

All Beef Hot Dog

Served with french fries, rice or vegetables

Pasta

Your choice of butter, cheese sauce or marinara

Mama Mia Pizzeria

5-inch pizza pie

Funnel Cake "Fries"

Ice Cream Sundae