Menus
Appetizers
-
Smoked Fish Spread
House-smoked whitefish and pickled vegetables, served with club crackers and lemon wedges
-
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Cocktail sauce, lemon, choose hot or cold
gluten free
-
Crab Cake
Traditional style blue crab cake, lightly breaded and seared, topped with pineapple and jalapeño salsa, key lime aioli
-
Grouper Nuggets (when available)
Black grouper bites breaded and fried, served with Critter tartar sauce
-
Crunchy Fried Shrimp
Sea Critter’s signature almond-crusted shrimp, with house-made cocktail sauce
-
Fried Calamari
Tender calamari breaded and fried in our own seasoned flour, served with Sweet Thai Chili Sauce
-
Hush Puppies
Lightly fried cornbread fritters served with a house-made remoulade for dipping
Soup
-
Tomato Crab Bisque
Our signature tomato basil bisque topped with a mound of chilled Blue Crab just before serving
gluten free
Salads
-
Critter House
Mixed greens, grape tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, feta crumbles, sunflower seeds, sun-dried tomato vinaigrette
gluten free
-
Caesar
Crunchy romaine hearts, garlic herb croutons, shredded parmesan cheese, lemon caesar dressing
-
Greek
Mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, pepperoncini, cucumbers, olives, red onions, peppers, feta crumbles, oregano vinaigrette
gluten free
-
Add-Ons
Shrimp, Chicken, or Fresh Fish (Choose either Grilled or Blackened)
gluten free
Sandwiches and Such
All Sandwiches include one choice of Homemade Creamy Cole Slaw or Thick-Cut Steak Fries. Sweet Potato Fries add .99-
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breasts brushed with a tangy BBQ sauce, with lettuce and tomato on a brioche bun
-
The Critter Burger
8 oz Angus beef patty, grilled with lettuce and tomato and special sauce on a brioche bun
-
Maine Lobster Roll
Slow poached lobster meat, celery, tossed with an herbed buttermilk dressing, served on a New England style bun
-
Fresh Catch Sandwich
Choose from today’s choice of market-fresh fish prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried or crunchy almond-crusted
-
Cuban
House-smoked mojo pork, ham, salami, swiss cheese, yellow mustard sauce and pickles served on pressed Ybor Cuban bread
House Specialties
-
Today’s Fresh Catch
Choose from today’s choice of market-fresh fish prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried, or crunchy almond-crusted and choice of two sides
gluten free
-
BBQ Chicken Plate
Grilled chicken breasts brushed with a tangy BBQ sauce, served with choice of two sides
gluten free
-
Dos Fish Tacos
Flour tortillas, pineapple pico, chipotle crema, pickled red onion, and cilantro. Choose from today’s choice of market-fresh fish prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried, or crunchy almond-crusted, served with creamy coleslaw and thick-cut fries
-
Fish And Chips
Beer battered haddock, Critter tartar sauce, served with creamy coleslaw and thick-cut steak fries
-
Sirloin Steak
Grilled grass-fed beef, served with choice of two sides
gluten free
-
Crab Cakes
Traditional style blue crab cakes, lightly breaded and seared, topped with pineapple and jalapeño salsa, key lime aioli, served with choice of two sides
-
Lobster Pasta
Maine Lobster medallions, spinach, basil, vine-ripened tomatoes, sautéed in a lobster white wine butter sauce, parmesan cheese with angel hair pasta
-
Sea Scallops
Jumbo sea scallops, with tartar sauce, prepared your way – grilled, blackened, fried, or crunchy almond-crusted, served with creamy coleslaw and thick-cut steak fries.
gluten free
-
Jambalaya
House-made jambalaya with andouille sausage, shrimp and chicken, served over rice
gluten free
-
Shrimp & Grits
Shrimp and andouille sausage sauteed with red bell pepper and onions in a cajun cream sauce, served on top of creamy smoked gouda grits
Sides
-
Caribbean Rice
gluten free
-
Creamy Coleslaw
gluten free
-
Black Beans
gluten free
-
Sidewinder French Fries
-
Sautéed Vegetables
gluten free
-
Sweet Potato Fries
Kids Menu
Children 10 and younger only-
Grilled Cheese "Better than Mom's"
Served with french fries, rice or vegetables
-
"Old Salty's" Fried Shrimp (4)
Served with french fries, rice or vegetables
-
Kid's Burger
Served with french fries, rice or vegetables
-
"Go Fish" Fried Grouper Nuggets
No "square fish" served here! Served with french fries, rice or vegetables
-
Chicken Tenders
Served with french fries, rice or vegetables
-
All Beef Hot Dog
Served with french fries, rice or vegetables
-
Pasta
Your choice of butter, cheese sauce or marinara
-
Mama Mia Pizzeria
5-inch pizza pie
-
Funnel Cake "Fries"
-
Ice Cream Sundae
Daily Specials (1/27/23)
-
Drink Special: Gaspar's Punch
-
App Special: Roasted Red Pepper Hummus With Grilled Naan
-
Special: Mexican Street Corn Shrimp Rice Bowl
Fresh Fish
-
Fresh Black Grouper, Cobia, Mahi, Sheepshead
Vegetable of the day
-
Green Beans
Soups of the Day
-
Tomato Crab Bisque
-
Chili con Carne
House Wine
-
Chardonnay
-
Pinot Grigio
-
Cabernet Sauvignon
-
Merlot
White & Rosé
-
Rosé
Studio by Miroval, France
-
Pinot Grigio
Chloe, Italy
-
Sauvignon Blanc
Kim Crawford, Marlborough, New Zealand
-
Chardonnay
Sonoma Cutrer, Russian River Valley
Red Wine
-
Pinot Noir
Ammunition, Sonoma Valley
-
Cabernet Sauvignon
J. Lohr, Paso Robles
-
Malbec
Trapiche, California
Sparkling
-
Prosecco
La Luca, Spain (Split)
Beer and Such
-
Michelob Ultra
-
Miller Lite
-
Corona
-
Blue Moon
-
Lil Sumpin'
-
Big Storm Hard Seltzer
-
Hard Cider (Rotating)
-
Bud Light Draft
-
Yuengling Draft
-
Jai Alai Draft
-
Other Rotating Draft and Package Selections (Ask your Server or Bartender)
Mocktails
-
Basil Lemonade
Fresh basil, lemon, sugar
-
Ginger Berry Bash
Ginger beer, berries, lemon
Margaritas
-
Critters’ Classic
Margaritaville Silver, Bols Triple Sec, Critter’s Sour
-
Pineapple Jalapeno
Dulce Vida, Naranja Orange Liqueur, Fresh Lime Juice
-
The Platinum
Milagro Blanco, Cointreau, Critter's Sour, Grand Marnier Float
-
Prickly Pear
Salt Berry Tequila, Prickly Pear Puree, Fresh Lime Juice
Tropical Specialties
-
Sunrise In Miami
E11even Vodka, Soda, Burnt Orange
-
Pass-A-Grille Punch
Wicked Dolphin Vanilla Rum, Drambuie, Pineapple Juice, Grenadine
-
Blueberry Bourbon Lemonade
Benchmark Bourbon, Blueberry Puree, Lemon Juice
-
Cucumber Mint Cooler
Stolichnaya Cucumber Vodka, Fresh Mint, Lemon Juice, Seltzer
-
Reef Runner
Wicked Dolphin Mango Rum, Wicked Dolphin Coconut Rum, Orange Juice, Blue Curacao Float
-
Chocolate Old Fashion
Salt Chocolate Tequila, Wicked Dolphin Vanilla Rum, Chocolate Bitters, Simple Syrup
-
Midsummer Night
Islamorada Hibiscus Gin, St. Germain, Simple Syrup, Lemon Juice, Seltzer
-
Pineapple Guava Mojito
Wicked Dolphin Pineapple Rum, Fresh Mint, Guava Puree, Seltzer
-
Gulf Sangria
Red or White Made From Scratch
Frozen Fun
-
Pina Colada
Wicked Dolphin Pineapple Rum, Coconut Cream, Wicked Dolphin Black Rum Float
-
Banana Daiquiri
Wicked Dolphin Banana Rum, Banana Cream, Wicked Dolphin Gold Rum Float
-
Mango Passionfruit Colada
Wicked Dolphin Mango Rum, Coconut Cream, Passionfruit Puree
Shell Key Martinis
-
Coco Melon
Wicked Dolphin Coconut Rum, Melon Liquor, Fresh Pineapple Juice
-
Sunset Dream
Old St. Pete Orange Sunset Gin, Licor 43, Orange Juice
-
Key Lime Pie
Big Strom Vanilla Vodka, Licor 43, Fresh Lime Juice, Cream
-
Pistachio
Di Amore Amaretto, Blue Curacao, Baileys, Cream
-
Coco-Rita
1800 Coconut, Cointreau, simple syrup, lime
-
Pineapple Jalapeno Margarita
Dulce Vida Pineapple Jalapeno tequila, Cointreau, lime, simple syrup
-
Prickly Pear Margarita
Salt Berry Tequila, Cointreau, prickly pear syrup, lime, fresh berries
-
Cucumber Cooler
Hendricks Gin, St. Germain, lime, mint, cucumber
-
Blueberry Bourbon Lemonade
Old Forester Bourbon, blueberry syrup, lemon juice, simple syrup, blueberries
-
Vina Del Mar
Platinum 7X Vodka, Cointreau, grapefruit juice, grenadine
-
Passion Fruit Margarita
Espolon Silver, Cointreau, lime juice, Passionfruit